Go Back   FormKaos: Board > General Discussion > Coffee Lounge
FAQ Community Arcade Today's Posts Search

Coffee Lounge Talk amongst other community members.

Reply
 
LinkBack Topic Tools Rate Topic
  #1 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
Bringing Sexy Back
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
*SunShyne* is on a distinguished road
Should they be charged?

SOURCE.

Quote:
DEERFIELD, Ill. (AP) – A couple have been charged with allowing their son to have an underage drinking party in their home, after which two teenage partygoers were killed in a car crash.

Jeffrey Hutsell, 53, and Sara Hutsell, 52, were charged with five misdemeanours, including endangering the health of a child and attempting to obstruct justice, police said Tuesday. Both were freed on US$5,000 bail after turning themselves in Friday.


Officials allege the Hutsells allowed their teenage son to have a party in their basement where beer and rum were served. Two 18-year-olds who authorities say attended the party, Daniel Bell and Ross Trace, were later killed in a car crash not far from the Hutsells' home.


Bell, who was driving, had a blood-alcohol level of 0.13 per cent, according to autopsy results. The legal limit for drivers older than 21 is 0.08. Toxicology reports also show Trace had marijuana in his system.


Prosecutors allege that the Hutsells knew what the teenagers were doing.
"The defendants were home, aware of the gathering, failed to control the party, failed to control access to their home (and) failed to control children's access to alcohol," said Dan Shanes, the assistant state's attorney. "Alcohol was freely and readily available to all the kids who were there, at least a couple dozen who came in and out."


There was no immediate response Wednesday to messages seeking comment that were left at numbers listed for the Hutsell in Deerfield.


you know, these "kids" were 18 years old... if they didn't know the consequenses of drinking and driving, then they deserved what their fate held for them. It's nailed into your head at a very young age that drinking and driving is not a good choice.



As for the parents... I have no problems with them.



They had their 18 year old son host a party for his 18 year old friends and got alcohol for them... end of the semester... why the heck not?



They were probably sitting upstairs in their living room "supervising" this party... unaware that some douchebag with an ego the size of the pole he crashed into was going to be an idiot and get behind the wheel.



If anything, the kid's parents should be charged with child endangerment... for clearly not warning him of the dangers of drinking and driving... not some parents who wanted to do something nice for their kid at the end of the term...



douchebags...
Reply With Quote
  #2 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
omega_image's Avatar
THE COBBLES ARE COMING.
 
Join Date: Nov 2000
omega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the rough
these parents should definitely be charged.

having a party where everyone is of age and is responsible for themselves is one thing. but having a bunch of underage kids at your residence getting drunk and not demanding keys or them to spend the night is plain fucking stupid.
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
bleep
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
b0ld is a jewel in the roughb0ld is a jewel in the roughb0ld is a jewel in the roughb0ld is a jewel in the rough
should of given them guns instead
Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
Bringing Sexy Back
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
*SunShyne* is on a distinguished road
Quote:
Originally Posted by omega_image View Post
these parents should definitely be charged.

having a party where everyone is of age and is responsible for themselves is one thing. but having a bunch of underage kids at your residence getting drunk and not demanding keys or them to spend the night is plain fucking stupid.

THEY'RE 18!!!!


I nominate this kid for the Darwin awards... we really needed some guy like that outta the gene pool.

I don;'t understand how you can't see the fault in someone who is 18, technically an adult (can legally vote!!!)
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
bleep
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
b0ld is a jewel in the roughb0ld is a jewel in the roughb0ld is a jewel in the roughb0ld is a jewel in the rough
Quote:
Originally Posted by *SunShyne* View Post

THEY'RE 18!!!!


I nominate this kid for the Darwin awards... we really needed some guy like that outta the gene pool.

I don;'t understand how you can't see the fault in someone who is 18, technically an adult (can legally vote!!!)


you have to understand the education system down there is not up to par....
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
Bringing Sexy Back
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
*SunShyne* is on a distinguished road
fair enough
Reply With Quote
  #7 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
omega_image's Avatar
THE COBBLES ARE COMING.
 
Join Date: Nov 2000
omega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the roughomega_image is a jewel in the rough
who gives a shit if they can vote? the legal drinking age in the states is 21. the parents knew what was going on, knew that there was underage drinking and didnt control it.

i have no problem with kids drinking, but since the parents allowed these kids to enter their residence and drink they are legally responsible.
Reply With Quote
  #8 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
C_squared's Avatar
thread killer
 
Join Date: Jan 2003
C_squared is a jewel in the roughC_squared is a jewel in the roughC_squared is a jewel in the rough
Quote:
Originally Posted by *SunShyne* View Post

THEY'RE 18!!!!


I nominate this kid for the Darwin awards... we really needed some guy like that outta the gene pool.

I don;'t understand how you can't see the fault in someone who is 18, technically an adult (can legally vote!!!)
If you really want to make a difference, move state-side, get an american citizenship and vote republican.
Reply With Quote
  #9 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
Bringing Sexy Back
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
*SunShyne* is on a distinguished road
...no thanks.

1) I'd be impressed if I got into the states, seeing has how I'm not allowed in them (must be my democratic attitude)
2) One person cannot make a difference... fuck those NBC commercials
3) The bud here is better
4) I want my kids growing up in a society where they shouldn't be afraid to be politically incorrect
Reply With Quote
  #10 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
the fink it girl
 
Join Date: May 2005
thechix0r is on a distinguished road
I think the parents should be charged. Just like at a bar, if you are hosting an alcoholic event, you are responsible for their actions while they are in your household, especially if they are underage and they are drinking and their parents were aware of this. They should have been responsible for them, even if they are 18 or not and took the keys from everyone who was drinking and perhaps provided a ride home if this was a party that they were doing for their kids.

Regardless if they know that drunk driving is bad, when you are under the influence you tend to feel invincible and perhaps this kid was no different. It's the parents responsiblity and they didn't take action.
Reply With Quote
  #11 (permalink)  
Old Dec 27, 06
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
project.one has a spectacular aura aboutproject.one has a spectacular aura aboutproject.one has a spectacular aura about
I can understand where the parents were coming from.

At 18 kids will do as they wish regardless of what the parents say. The parents probably wanted to have the kids drinking in a safe environment where they knew they would be ok. As opposed to them all just going to some bush party and driving there and back or something along thoes lines.

The parents probably could have kept a better eye on things.
I believe the parents should be charges, because good intentions or not, they broke the law. However, I personaly dont think they should have the book thrown at them. But not let free either.

But thats just how I would look at it.
Reply With Quote
  #12 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
Beware the Toes
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Webber will become famous soon enough
Parents should be fined at the most, no jail time or criminal record - they were all 18 after all

if you're the one driving then it is up to you to know your limit, admitt when you can't drive.

as for the passenger, just as at fault as the driver - don't drive with some one who is tanked
Reply With Quote
  #13 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
don´t worry be happy
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
MarcelM is on a distinguished road
They somehow proved the parents knew alcohol was served and therefore they are responsible for what is going on in their property, but I don´t know if you can connect this responsibility to the fact one idiot went behind the wheel... that´s his responsibility, he has probably had his licence for over two years, so he knows what´s going on.
Anyway, in my opinion, and I keep repeating it, driving age lower than drinking age is a bad bad rule.
Reply With Quote
  #14 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
Boom. Boom.
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Caps/\L0cK is an unknown quantity at this point
Quote:
Originally Posted by omega_image View Post
who gives a shit if they can vote? the legal drinking age in the states is 21. the parents knew what was going on, knew that there was underage drinking and didnt control it.

i have no problem with kids drinking, but since the parents allowed these kids to enter their residence and drink they are legally responsible.


Whoo Gives. A. FUCK.

fuck legally respinsible, by 18 you can make your own desisions. The only difference having the party at a house made was .:LESS PEOPLE DROVE TO AND FRO THE PARTY:. Otherwise woulda been somewhere at a park or in the bush, and like 1/2 the kids would have driven there.

So far as i am concerned if the kid is stupid enough to drink and drive the parents hold no responsibility on those actions once the kids leave their property.

It would be like a bar tender noking you to the floor and taking your keys becuz he sensed you were going to drive home.

NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.

Parents should be let off, and the kids grave should be trod upon for his stupidity.

I am 18 and i have no respect for anyone who DD's

Its stupid, and it gets people killed.

Just last night a kid i know in gr 11 was driving his parents car, without a lisence and drunk as fuck... straght into a ditch .... (Failed to use a roundabout properly, just went over it and into a ditch)

Well lucky for him, he called his parents and his dad came before the cops and pretended that he was driving. The kid wasnt hurt, but the next time i see him im going to slap him and tell him to not be such a dumbass.

If i had seen him go to leave in the car had he not crashed. And seen how drunk he was. I probably would have gotten a few friends grabbed him, drove him home and his car.

Me and my friends were not drinking and driving. Only 2 guys were drinking and they were not drivers. We did however smoke a shit load of weed. However at one point we left to go somewhere and i said , No.. You are too baked to drive, give it 1/2 an hour... once wed sat around listening to music and felt attentive enough, and not as baked 45 minutes later my friend drove us home.

And as an exmaple, the last time a friend of mine tried to leave a party and go driving drunk, we grabbed him and took his keys, locked his car and then walked his ass home (he only lived 3 blocks away) .. he got his car in the morning.

So fuck these police, leave the rents alone. Its the kids fault entirely.
Reply With Quote
  #15 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
not colbert
 
Join Date: Oct 2003
stephen_c will become famous soon enoughstephen_c will become famous soon enough
Quote:
Originally Posted by *SunShyne* View Post

THEY'RE 18!!!!


I nominate this kid for the Darwin awards... we really needed some guy like that outta the gene pool.

I don;'t understand how you can't see the fault in someone who is 18, technically an adult (can legally vote!!!)


complain all u want.
the law is the law
no drinkin under 21 in the states.
and obviously no dwi.
18 voting age is irrelevant.

it's similar in canada
legally, drinkin age is 19 and voting age is 18.

there was a movement to lower voting age to 16
http://www.vote16.ca/en/index.htm
the bill got defeated.
voting at w/e age is a privilege to participate.
it does not automatically make u an adult.
Reply With Quote
  #16 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
don´t worry be happy
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
MarcelM is on a distinguished road
Quote:
Originally Posted by Caps/\L0cK View Post
Whoo Gives. A. FUCK.



Me and my friends were not drinking and driving. Only 2 guys were drinking and they were not drivers. We did however smoke a shit load of weed. However at one point we left to go somewhere and i said , No.. You are too baked to drive, give it 1/2 an hour... once wed sat around listening to music and felt attentive enough, and not as baked 45 minutes later my friend drove us home.

And as an exmaple, the last time a friend of mine tried to leave a party and go driving drunk, we grabbed him and took his keys, locked his car and then walked his ass home (he only lived 3 blocks away) .. he got his car in the morning.

So fuck these police, leave the rents alone. Its the kids fault entirely.

Society should see you and your friends as role models !!
Reply With Quote
  #17 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
dabbler's Avatar
Art Is Resistance
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
dabbler is a jewel in the roughdabbler is a jewel in the roughdabbler is a jewel in the roughdabbler is a jewel in the rough
their age doesn't matter, anyone leaving that party drunk could have done worse and killed someone else on the road. the person who throws the party can be held responsible even if they were adults
Reply With Quote
  #18 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
Grapes's Avatar
ceiling cat!
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Grapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to all
Did the parents "throw the party", or did they just allow it to happen?

Also there's a seperation between the crimes of "providing underage kids with a place to drink and party" and "drinking and driving" (and subsequently getting killed).

Obviously the parents are on the hook for the former. Are the responsible for the latter? Should every host of a party (underage or otherwise) be held legally liable if someone from that party who is hammered gets behind the wheel?

No-one would blame the hosts of a party at which everyone's of age for a subsequent DUI death. The crux is whether you think the fact that the homeowners were parents and the partiers were kids changes that. To my mind they're negligible, but not responsible.
Reply With Quote
  #19 (permalink)  
Old Dec 28, 06
http://virb.com/esoter1c
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
esoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to allesoter1c is a name known to all
Society likes to pick leaves off of the trees to solve problems.

The root causes never found.
Reply With Quote
  #20 (permalink)  
Old Dec 29, 06
sup?
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
tiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to all
I say to the gallows with all of 'em. Make an example out of them even if they didn't do anything wrong! Example are neat.
Reply With Quote
  #21 (permalink)  
Old Dec 29, 06
Grapes's Avatar
ceiling cat!
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Grapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to all
What's the example? "Here's what happens to you if you don't do anything wrong!!!"
Reply With Quote
  #22 (permalink)  
Old Dec 29, 06
sup?
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
tiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to alltiedye is a name known to all
"Tough shit."
Reply With Quote
  #23 (permalink)  
Old Dec 29, 06
GO SENS!
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Séguin will become famous soon enough
The couple could be held responsible for allowing them alcohol, but that's all. Seeing how they were above the age of majority and are fully aware of whats going on around them, the 18 year olds are fully responsible for their own actions.
Reply With Quote
  #24 (permalink)  
Old Dec 29, 06
Grapes's Avatar
ceiling cat!
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Grapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to allGrapes is a name known to all
Quote:
Originally Posted by tiedye View Post
"Tough shit."
Good thing you're not in charge of anything.
Reply With Quote
  #25 (permalink)  
Old Dec 29, 06
'latinum respect.
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
miss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to allmiss.myra is a name known to all
honestly, when horrible things happen and the responsible parties are dead they usually look for the next group of people to take their frustration out on, and isn't that wonderful? Instead of trying to use this for good, they have decided to punish people as some kind of deterrent.

while i understand this situation is unfortunate, 18 year olds are not stupid and if they can legally vote, drive a car and face charges as an adult, then they sure as hell are mentally capable of knowing the difference between right and wrong...

people just look for someone to blame to hope it will bring their children back and i find more and more these days people are unwilling to accept someone had a lapse in good judgement, people win millions of dollars for suing companies because their coffee was hot and they burned their legs when it spilled and were not properly warned on the cup. come on.
Reply With Quote
Reply


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 07:29 PM.


Forum software by vBulletin
Circa 2000 FNK.CA