|
Coffee Lounge Talk amongst other community members. |
|
LinkBack | Topic Tools | Rate Topic |
|
||||
Naked suspect dies after stun gun use - UPI.com
Damn't they should have realized this guy was depressed too, totally not his fault he robbed a bank naked. |
|
|||
Quote:
Now,what pisses me off about your rebuttals is the negative undertones pertaining to PPD. You shouldnt try to discredit something you obviously know so very little about first or second hand :) Your arguement is bullshit, its like arguing about a vagina or arguing about breasts...or abortion. So yes, its safe to say that you cant speak NEGATIVELY about something that you havent experienced. Thats my whole point here. I am not giving a get out of jail free card,I am simply showing empathy,compassion and understanding for a fellow human being regardless of her background.Maybe you should do a bit of the same?I dont think its acceptable to crucify someone completely when you yourself do not know the full story, maybe entertain some of the thoughts ive given and once you look past your own contempt for me then hopefully youll be able to see that they are probable cause. |
|
|||
^its not okay but it gives an explanation for the action. PPD changes a person like all other mental illness,so often the persons actions are manifestations of the illness itself and not of the person.
Like someone whos bipolar,when theyre not manic theyre not out being hypersexual,shooting meth and going on shopping sprees at Holt...right? Its a manifestation of the illness,not of the person. The illness takes over the person. |
|
||||
I like how you have stated as a fact that she has PPD.
Even though your only evidence is she has a child. I would ask you to consider the fact that she's 16 with a child, the mother never stated any problem with the police taking the child away (just the technique used), the ministry of family development had her under supervision and monitoring before this incident, the mother was already living in a group home (which she was missing from) or the quote: "The mother - who suffers from mental health problems - was taken to hospital under the mental health act." This would lead most people to believe that she has a history of mental health problems. However, even if this was just PPD, then how would this change the fact that the child's life was in danger. As a side note, I talked to a friend who works at 1130, the reason this went orginally to news is because the mother and grandmother called several media outlets hours after it happened telling their sob story. However upon finding out the issues surrounding it, all media outlets realized that it was an unavoidable circumstance. Why do you think there hasn't been any other media coverage for this event after the first story? As bad as it is, this is a teenager with mental issues that was with holding life saving medical treatment from a child and smothering her child. Police stepped in and after several hours had to use a taser. This wasn't shot at the teenager, it was applied directly to her back so the chances of her child being hit was nil. It's a shitty situation, but it had to be done. At least till the new shipment of ninja blowdarts the VPD ordered from the back of Amazing adventures #221 arrives in the mail next week. Last edited by NinjaBoy; Oct 03, 08 at 10:55 AM. |
|
|||
^ the current of electricity can travel right? I didnt state PPD as a fact, I stated it as a propable cause. If she has a history of mental illness it also makes her that much more suseptable to getting PPD which makes it even more probable that she was suffering from that and her actions were a manifestation of the circumstances as well as possible PPD or baby blues at minimum. Quit trying to twist my words and take them out of context to prove your point.
They did not say she was 100% smothering her child, they said it looked like a possibility on how she was holding the child. Youre taking the reports out of context to serve your own purpose which is to villify this young girl at whatever costs. I think the situation could have been avoided all together by not getting the police involved at all, when a person is emotionally and mentally unstable the police arent seen in that state as a helpful outlet, thus making the situation deteriorate even more so as soon as they arrive on scene. I beleive a neutral third party unrelated to the ministry and to the police could have been used to defuse the situation as opposed to using police force which escalated the situation. Maybe they could have sent a nurse, medics...a pediatrician? Maybe even someone the mother trusted like a friend or family member? There needs to be better procedures in place to avoid a potentially tragic situation. If she was a foster kid and had a child while in care its the ministries standard procedure to monitor the parent(s),when you factor in mental health issues and an emotionally stressful situation is it any wonder to you that the mother reacted the way that she did? |
|
|||||
Uh, no. I though this was well established?
Quote:
Quote:
You are taking all the reports out of context and ignoring them to make the teen seem like the victim. Quote:
Quote:
Sure in a perfect world, everytime there is an issue it would be handled without police involvement. But that's not the case, and expecting that to occur during any serious incident is just crazy. Quote:
I can't help you. I've stated it sucks, and it shouldn't have happend. But if you insist on living in a world where all the world's problems can be solved without force not mater the litigating factors, then so be it. I'll be waiting over here with the rest of society who realizes that just wishing that everything would work out nicely doesn't mean it will. |
|
||||
Quote:
Regardless of whether or not her action is explainable, that doesn't make it right. |
|
|||
and regardless of whether or the not the cops actions are explainable doesnt make thiers right either.
Ninjaboy, i did not say she had PPD for a fact. I said that based on the circumstances it is quite probable that she does. I dont see how you can misunderstand that, but anyways. Also, social services or anyone from the ministry of family and children arent a neutral third party. Sure they were on site, and probably escalating the situation well before the police were called,cops show up and it gets out of control. anyways,this is pointless so im removing myself from this "discussion". |
|
|
Similar Topics | ||||
Topic | Topic Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
The new Rogers/Fido iPhone 3G Rate Plans | narc | Coffee Lounge | 84 | Aug 06, 08 08:14 AM |
Cell phones!!! $10 a month unlimited! | LastWerd | Coffee Lounge | 31 | Jan 12, 06 04:06 PM |
NorthWestJungle.com - October Update - This Month: Azrael - 'Blunted up North' | Turns | Other Locations | 0 | Oct 02, 05 05:02 PM |
Breast cancer awarness month | krisamata | Coffee Lounge | 7 | Oct 27, 04 08:05 PM |
web hosting: 1GB space 10GB transfer $10 / month | djpressure | Classifieds | 1 | Sep 08, 04 04:30 PM |