Quote:
Originally Posted by cheebus420
you think joining the "Canadian Army" makes you honorable? When in the face of history have we found murder something to be proud of? No matter how you justify defending your morals, your country, your beliefs... you're a warrior. You're trained to kill for the government, to protect what?
Follow any war in human history, and find me one that was done for justice? Behind every one is profit, no matter for what gain. Fighting for liberation, for justice, against an oppresive regiem, now that's honerable. Fighting against slavery, ignorance, racism, that's honerable. Joining the military because it's cool? That's disgusting.
|
Boy have you picked the wrong person. I dont smoke, drink alcohol, coffee, coca cola, shop at brand name stores, do any sort of stimulant, break any laws, and i dont own a car b/c i believe people should take mass transit. Im joining the army because i think EVERYONE should; it would build character, it would increase the fitness level of the population, it would increase the intelligence and technical skill level of the population, it would increase our preparedness as a society to cope with disasters, and i think it would actually decrease violence in our society.
I just got a BA from UBC, dble major history and classical studies. My focus is Demographics and ancient warfare. As Achilles says in the new movie 'Troy': how can you understand war until you have experienced it yourself. So as a scholar, i think it is my duty to get military training. Canada, I dont much care for because there are maybe too many freedoms, not enough ways to enforce laws and too many assholes abusing things like welfare, EI, Unions, pensions, and other solcialist programs. That being said, i am in favor of responsible socialism, such as exists in countries like finland and sweden (which have mandatory military service). If i did not live what i believed in, I would be a hypocrite.
North Americans have 80% of the world's wealth, and the world WANTS IT BACK! So im a warrior defending our stuff? SO what. When the US come for our water, or the Chinese come for our lumber, or the Germans come for our steel, or whoever it is and whatever they want, they will negotiate first, but it usually boils down to conflict.
War is stupid, silly and wrong. Most Canadians have evolved above it. But the rest of the world doesnt have our education or the morals created by the ruthless bias and propaganda force fed to us since we were children. So they in many ways are still savage. They cant negotiate, They have only one option. And they dont even see it as wrong.
So you see, the world is not ready yet for no war. candada is. Certain socialist european countries are. But unitil the rest of the world is, we must be on our guard. Look at (lame annalogy but accurate) Star Trek.
They had to have weapons even though they were peaceful because it was necessary. We will never agree on everything.
As for the second paragraph, Justice is a Poor choice of words. That practicaly justifies about half the wars ever waged. Also, according to your words, suicide bombing is honorable. But im not going to touch that with a 20 foot pole, because ive been typing for a while. A main point you should think about is that everything is biased. You are biased against war, but blind to the causes, necessities, etc etc etc. As a historian i must remember to see both sides of an issue, to truly understand it well that is essential. So realize that I am against fighting, killing and destruction, but still see good reason the military is needed. Law enforcement, peacekeeping, hazardous area work, firefighting, field medicine, security, administration... these things are all done by soldiers.
As Canadian soldiers, we exist to defend our country and to spread our ideals of peace, security and equality abroad. Money and politicians and laws can only do so much. We are simply acting as one of the tools being used to make this place better.
I hope this makes you understand my point of view better.